physics2 min read

Rehbinder Effect: Today I Learnt

Experimental physics and nature hacks could ever stem solely by theoretical work?

While watching YouTube, I stumbled upon the following video demonstrating the Rehbinder effect. I was not aware of such phenomena, and it caught my attention by its unexpected results.

In the video, we can see how hammering an iron nail through the bottom of a ceramic cup results in the shattering of the cup.

But if the cup is positioned upside down in a container full of water (in a way that the liquid forms a thin film over the surface), suddenly the nail can just pass through it forming a circular hole without causing any damage.

Physics Explanation

The effect is described in Wikipedia as:

[…] the reduction in the hardness and ductility of a material, particularly metals, by a surfactant film.

The phenomena in the video is explained as a combination of both the Rehbinder effect, and the fact that water absorbs way more vibrations than air and that - being a liquid - is effectively non-compressible.

From what I could understand, there are plausible explanations of the Rehbinder effect1 but the phenomena is not completely understood.

Nature Hacks

Anything that looks like magic always catches my attention. Magicians and illusionists manipulate your perceptions with sophisticated tricks. Nature has its cheats too.

When the hacks are real and intrinsic to physics, I always remain in awe. I wonder if we could learn or discover such tricks from purely theoretical developments. For example, Dirac explains how the positron was a theoretical discovery driven by the elegance of the equations. How far can we really push the theory before the need of reconnecting it with experimental knowledge and direct experience?

Humans have this tremendous power of being able to catch a glimpse of understanding of the universe a-posteriori, i.e., only after interacting with it and experiencing its reaction2. Perhaps we will never be able to master the deepest roots of reality, and that might be the whole point of going through the human experience.

Footnotes

  1. Some resources:

    ↩
  2. The fact that the experimental method works and we can actually understand anything is a mystery in and of itself. ↩

← All writing